?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Viva la revolucion! ????

I know you have come to kill me. Shoot, coward, you are only going to kill a man.

these were the last words of Che Guevera before the Bolivians (and the CIA) gave him a dose of his own medicine and executed him.
These were also the words I found at the end of an email yesterday....an email from a friend of mine who is a human rights activist.

can someone please explain to me why Che Guevera is such a hero? i don't get it...... i never have...
i apologize in advance if my words about the man offend your sense of revolutionary heroism....
fuck it, no i don't. this is my journal. defend him here...help me understand. tell me why he is the romanticized symbol of revolution, in his little beret, rifle resting on his shoulder?

i am also tired of hearing how academia and those on the left sympathize with the Castros and Che. i am pretty damn left and i don't. i subscribe to some of Castro's ideals..... but not the imprisonment of those with voices, the book burnings, the midnight murders, inhumane prison conditions and the refusal to allow the Red Cross or Amnesty International to visit them.....

yeah, i think capitalism is the root of all evil. i am a socialist and a neo-Marxist. (why, too, do people use the words socialist and communist interchangeably?....think sweden not china....chavez not shwe)
Marx never suggested the way to deal with dissidents is to tie their hands behind their backs and blow their brains out. i'm sorry, but i don't think Marx would have befriended a man who believed the best place for women was as cooks or nurses. while Marx understood violence could be a component of revolution, he did not consider it necessary.

in Guerrilla Warfare, Che wrote, "Marx always recommended that once the revolutionary process has begun the proletariat should strike blows again and again without rest. "
did he not understand Marx didn't mean gunshot blows? and the blows were to be against the bourgeoisie, not the proletariat - the very folks for whom he should have been fighting?

Marx's revolutionary process was in the hands of the workers overthrowing the ruling class. Che was neither of the worker class nor for them. i don't have the quote at my fingertips, but i am pretty sure he made some comment along the way in his diaries about the "peasants not helping us at all."

“I ended the problem with a .32 caliber pistol, in the right side of his brain."
revolutionary.

do people ever think he led a peaceful revolution? that he wasn't directly responsible for thousands of executions, including children and peasants?

“hatred as an element of struggle; unbending hatred for the enemy, which pushes a human being beyond his natural limitations, making him into an effective, violent, selective, and cold-blooded killing machine. This is what our soldiers must become."
his hatred, unbending as it was, included "deviants" - children of political prisoners, christians, gays, people with AIDS, and others who "committed crimes against revolutionary morals". in fact, he set up a labor camp designed specifically for them, in which they many were tortured and executed. the sign over the camp read: Work Will Make Men out of You. (Auschwitz reminder, anyone?)
"To send men to the firing squad, judicial proof is unnecessary. These procedures are an archaic bourgeois detail. This is a revolution! And a revolutionary must become a cold killing machine motivated by pure hate."

in the middle of the Cuban missile crisis, Che supported all-out nuclear war. his position was that if the world was blown away, he could build a better one from the ashes. the ashes? the ashes of innocent people around the world? that was the price for his brand of freedom.
"We will march the path of victory even if it costs millions of atomic victims."
my opinion of the murderer aside (and i admit i am not extremely knowledgeable of Cuban history), someone please tell me one thing good that came from him? don't tell me about Batista..... because he just replaced one oppressive dictator for another even more so. don't tell me about economics because once he took over the State banks, the economic situation was worse than it had ever been and the people were reduced to rations - a system still in place today.
isn't it ironic that most Cubans see Che as evil while Americans glorify him?
i know a lot of people contribute to the capitalism of Che by wearing merchandise with his face plastered on it..... the sad truth is that i know many people do it because it is cool, or looks cool... or they think it is some symbol of liberal revolution and freedom.... but they really have no idea who the man was or what he did. with that said, i can only hope they think of his victims while his face rests over their hearts.
anyway, i responded to my friend's email.... i asked him why he chose a Che quote as an email tagline. turns out he really didn't know much about Che. he knew the icon.
next time you see someone wearing something Che, ask who he was..... i dare you.

Tags:

Comments

( 6 comments — Leave a comment )
untamedgirlie
Sep. 3rd, 2007 06:48 pm (UTC)
Of Che, i claim ignorance. But i do remembering seeing, when you and i were in Paris, a seemingly endless amount of merchandise with his face - purses, t-shirts, flags, bandanas - i didn't know who he was (i should have asked you!), so i wasn't interested in buying anything with his name or the slogan on it. Now i know, and i will ask others who wear his ideals...

Of Castro, i know much more (though definitely not a scholar on the subject). Although i am in the academia, a leftist, and an American - i have no sympathy for him. His revolution destroyed the lives of the masses - the unnamed. Until the day my grandfather died in his 90s, he had to get in line at 4 a.m. to obtain their rationed food for the day, or the week, depending on what was available. Everything is rationed, from food to clothing to vehicles and household items. Luxury items are relegated to the Castro regime and have no place in the homes of the masses. Regular Cuban citizens have no rights - no right to speak out, no right to self-governance, no right to expand their education beyond the Castro doctrine, no right to see their extended families who have fled his rule, no right to privacy, and on and on. They are, indeed, ruled by fear and comply by the same.

No, i have no sympathy for Castro.
melissamuse
Sep. 3rd, 2007 06:51 pm (UTC)
i remember seeing all the Che bags when we were looking for purses....
aren't you proud of me for not going off on a political rant right there on the sidewalk? :)
the_legionnaire
Sep. 3rd, 2007 10:23 pm (UTC)
Communism is a beautiful idea, but no 'regime' that has ever been labelled 'communism' has really been communism. China is not communist, they are absolutely capitalist.

As for Che... I guess he is just a good example of capitalist myth creation. Over-the-counter-culture. You want to be 'alternative', to go against the grain? Here you go. Put on a Cliche Guevara t-shirt and you're set.

One of the best slogan t-shirts I have ever seen had a hammer and sickle and the words 'This is not a fashion statement, I AM a communist'.
melissamuse
Sep. 3rd, 2007 10:36 pm (UTC)
yes, it is a beautiful idea...if it were ever implemented with its true intent and not by greedy dictators.
i love that tshirt :) i saw a Che one once... the typical one, but underneath it said, "I have no idea who he is."
honesty :)
a_dark_master
Sep. 4th, 2007 11:46 pm (UTC)
I will explain Che, when you can convince me that Ghandi's non violent revolution wasn't violent. That his fight for India's freedom from the crown didn't cost lives and that the governments established were topian in nature. No freedom was ever won without costs. And pacifism never won a battle.

Che was a soldier who put his life on the line for an ideal, whether you agree with it or not, he did not just write about it; he fought for what he believed would relieve the burden of the poor. As a result Castro brought public education to the masses as well as health care. What has this country done for its masses? Caused chaos in foreign lands causing more death and devastation than a so called mad man did.

We torture and kill, we rape and pillage in the name of democracy under the leadership of men and women who have never donned a weapon or fought a war. Che could have been anybody, but an American hero named Patrich Henry said (long before Marx or Che) "Give me liberty, or give me death"http://libertyonline.hypermall.com/henry-liberty.html

People die for what they believe, it is a price that heros pay. Even Joan d' Arch martyred herself in war, not peace.
melissamuse
Sep. 5th, 2007 01:55 pm (UTC)
i am not comparing american to cuba....if fact, anyone who knows me well knows how i feel about america.
here is my point (and you say Che fought for the poor)...Che was not poor, nor from a lower class background (nor even Cuban for that matter....his rampage and anger went across south america)....
if he fought for the poor, why did the peasant class rebel him? why, in the name of his brand of communism, did so many peasants who resisted giving up their farms, find their families with bullets in their brains?
i don't deny that cuba has its good points and i would even go so far as to say they may be in a better economic situation without the embargos....
but the murders? the burned books? the thousands of political prisoners? the beatings?
this isn't about the poor....Che was not about the poor. revolutions truly rarely are.....
Che quoted so muc Marx, but, again, Marx was about the proletariat rising up....not Che's class and reasons.
( 6 comments — Leave a comment )

Profile

don't fear death
melissamuse
melissa muses (or maia, you choose)

Roma

wandering does not make you a "gypsy."
why would you call yourself
after those who have no home?
long skirts and hoop earrings
do not make you a "gypsy."
why do you call yourself after
those who have no clothes?

"gypsy" is pejorative. please don't perpetuate the stereotype. educate yourself on what it really means to be a "gypsy" in this world.

Who are the Roma?

Decade of Roma Inclusion

Dženo Association

European Roma Rights Centre

Roma Balkans

Roma National Congress

Romani World

Rombase

Rroma

Rroma Media Network

Soros Roma Initiatives

Studii Romani

The European Union and Roma

The Patrin Webjournal: Romani Culture and History

Voice of Roma
World Bank Roma Initiatives

Have a Happy Day! :)

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow